Property
54 Fair Street • Town
$4,895,000
5 bd · 5.5 ba
Set along one of Nantucket Town's most charming and historic streets, 54 Fair is a beautifully renovated circa-1800 residence that pairs more than two centuries of island character with modern comfort. Just moments from Main Street, this five bedroom, five and a half bathroom home retains notable historic details, including original pine floors, chair rails and doors. The inviting floor plan offers beautifully appointed living, dining and kitchen spaces, a first-floor en suite bedroom, three additional en suite bedrooms on the second floor, and a spacious private primary suite occupying the third. Outside, a secluded brick patio, outdoor shower and off-street parking provide exceptional amenities for an in-Town property. Thoughtfully updated while preserving its historic character, this home offers a rare opportunity to own an authentic piece of old Nantucket just a short distance from the shops, restaurants and cobblestones of Main Street. Offered fully furnished and turnkey, this home presents an opportunity for immediate enjoyment, complemented by a strong rental history that adds to its appeal as both a Nantucket retreat and investment property.
Stephen's Take
Unlocking the un-googleable details.
This property requires local context to truly understand its value. Click below to get a direct, private assessment of its zoning potential, nitrogen constraints, and historical transaction reality.
Ask for Stephen's read on this propertyMLS Data
- Status
- Pending
- List price
- $4,895,000
- Beds / baths
- 5 bd · 5.5 ba
- Living area
- 2,538 sq ft
- Days on market
- 31
- Listing office
- William Raveis Nantucket
Set along one of Nantucket Town's most charming and historic streets, 54 Fair is a beautifully renovated circa-1800 residence that pairs more than two centuries of island character with modern comfort. Just moments from Main Street, this five bedroom, five and a half bathroom home retains notable historic details, including original pine floors, chair rails and doors. The inviting floor plan offers beautifully appointed living, dining and kitchen spaces, a first-floor en suite bedroom, three additional en suite bedrooms on the second floor, and a spacious private primary suite occupying the third. Outside, a secluded brick patio, outdoor shower and off-street parking provide exceptional amenities for an in-Town property. Thoughtfully updated while preserving its historic character, this home offers a rare opportunity to own an authentic piece of old Nantucket just a short distance from the shops, restaurants and cobblestones of Main Street. Offered fully furnished and turnkey, this home presents an opportunity for immediate enjoyment, complemented by a strong rental history that adds to its appeal as both a Nantucket retreat and investment property.
Assessor Record
- Location
- 54 FAIR ST
- Primary use
- Single Fam M01
- Zoning
- ROH
- Assessed total
- $3,593,800
- Acreage
- 0.05 ac
- Building area
- 2,538 sq ft
- Year built
- 1800
Registry Record
Latest deed reference: 1597/328
$2,200,000
2017-06-28 · Book / Page 1597/328
$2,250,000
2007-08-10 · Book / Page 1096/077
$1,275,000
1999-08-24 · Book / Page 0632/249
$550,000
1998-06-19 · Book / Page 0583/066
Recorded transfer
1976-07-01 · Book / Page 0154/228
Zoning Context
- District code
- ROH
- District name
- Residential Old Historic
Sample allowable uses
- Primary Dwelling
- Secondary dwelling
- Accessory dwelling
- Tertiary Dwelling
- Apartment — conditional / restricted
- Apartment building — conditional / restricted
Data Sources & Freshness
- Listing data
- MLS / LINKon market since 2026-08-13
- Assessment data
- Nantucket Assessorannual cycle
- Deed history
- Nantucket Registry of Deedsas recorded
- Zoning context
- Town of Nantucket zoning dataofficial reference
- Market analysis
- Nantucket Houses / Stephen Maury interpretationongoing