Property
42 Vestal Street • West of Town
$2,750,000
3 bd · 2 ba
Tucked away on a coveted corner lot where Vestal meets Winn, 42 Vestal Street captures the timeless charm of one of Nantucket’s most beloved in-town neighborhoods. Three bedrooms and two full bathrooms are spread across two floors, with a study that offers additional flexible space. A nearby Quaker cemetery lends the surrounding area an uncommon openness and calm, while beautiful exterior details including copper downspouts and rear deck invite long afternoons spent enjoying the property’s peaceful yet convenient setting.
Stephen's Take
Unlocking the un-googleable details.
This property requires local context to truly understand its value. Click below to get a direct, private assessment of its zoning potential, nitrogen constraints, and historical transaction reality.
Ask for Stephen's read on this propertyMLS Data
- Status
- Pending
- List price
- $2,750,000
- Beds / baths
- 3 bd · 2 ba
- Living area
- 1,924 sq ft
- Days on market
- 70
- Listing office
- Fisher Real Estate
Tucked away on a coveted corner lot where Vestal meets Winn, 42 Vestal Street captures the timeless charm of one of Nantucket’s most beloved in-town neighborhoods. Three bedrooms and two full bathrooms are spread across two floors, with a study that offers additional flexible space. A nearby Quaker cemetery lends the surrounding area an uncommon openness and calm, while beautiful exterior details including copper downspouts and rear deck invite long afternoons spent enjoying the property’s peaceful yet convenient setting.
Assessor Record
- Location
- 42 VESTAL ST
- Primary use
- Single Fam M01
- Zoning
- R1
- Assessed total
- $1,633,100
- Acreage
- 0.13 ac
- Building area
- 1,924 sq ft
- Year built
- 1837
Registry Record
Latest deed reference: 1339/137
Recorded transfer
2012-08-17 · Book / Page 1339/137
Recorded transfer
2012-08-17 · Book / Page 1339/135
Recorded transfer
1997-01-22 · Book / Page 0526/125
$315,000
1996-12-20 · Book / Page 0523/182
$337,000
1995-01-05 · Book / Page 0463/103
Zoning Context
- District code
- R1
- District name
- Residential 1
Sample allowable uses
- Primary Dwelling
- Secondary dwelling
- Accessory dwelling
- Tertiary Dwelling — conditional / restricted
- Apartment — conditional / restricted
- Apartment building — conditional / restricted
Data Sources & Freshness
- Listing data
- MLS / LINKon market since 2026-05-21
- Assessment data
- Nantucket Assessorannual cycle
- Deed history
- Nantucket Registry of Deedsas recorded
- Zoning context
- Town of Nantucket zoning dataofficial reference
- Market analysis
- Nantucket Houses / Stephen Maury interpretationongoing